The vice or weakness that is most offensive to me is undermining others’ ideas. Teaching undergraduates gives me a particularly direct view of how students interact. When the semester begins, it is a matter of few classes to identify those students who would rather criticize and make barbed comments about their fellow students, rather than communicate something positive.
Is this a vice? In my opinion, being ‘mean-spirited’ towards others in the class is a vice and a weakness. It reflects the true character of the student poking fun at others. Trying to be superior to others in an academic setting does undermine everyone’s efforts, including the professor’s efforts.
Being authentic and true to oneself, as well as supporting others work and studies is crucial in the process of writing and learning. When there are a few students who consistently undermine the process of learning and discussion, it is hurtful and counter-productive for everyone. I find that redirecting the tone and posturing of such students is a challenge. Some students have a bullying mentality, which is not acceptable in the college setting. It seems to me that this vice stems from years of cultural acceptance without restraint or corrective measures from those in charge of the student-body. My sense is that if they’re not reachable by means of ethical and logical measures, than I suggest that they withdraw from my class.
For some students, being asked to withdraw from class is sufficient pressure for them to modify their behavior. However, for many others, their inability to move beyond old behaviors and negative commentary either earns them a poor grade or obliges them to withdraw from my class. My hope is to motivate each student to achieve their academic goals and to do so without undermining others.